CIP-013-AB-2, CIP-003-AB-8, CIP-005-AB-7 & CIP-010-AB-4
Consultation has concluded
Forwarding Notice Forwarded and Approved
A forwarding notice for approval of proposed new CIP-013 and Supporting Standards was submitted on July 25, 2023 to the Alberta Utilities Commission. The AUC issued Decision 28354-D01-2023 on Aug. 25, 2022 approving proposed new CIP-013-AB-2 and Supporting Standards (CIP-003-AB-8, CIP-005-AB-7, CIP-010-AB-4), proposed new CIP-PLAN-AB-2 and retirement of existing CIP-003-AB-5, CIP-005-AB-5, CIP-010-AB-1, CIP-PLAN-AB-1 effective Oct. 1, 2024 (except for CIP-003-AB-8, requirement R2, which will have a staggered implementation timeline as detailed within the AESO’s application).
For information regarding the decision please visit the Commission’s eFiling site and go to proceeding #28354.
Background
The AESO consulted with Stakeholders on the CIP-013 (Critical Infrastructure Protection) and supporting standards (adoption of CIP-003-AB-8, CIP-005-AB-7, CIP-010-AB-4, CIP-013-AB-2 and the retirement of CIP-003-AB-5, CIP-005-AB-5 and CIP-010-AB-1) which are focused on addressing new cyber security challenges facing the Alberta Interconnected Electric System (AIES). Adoption of CIP-003-AB-8, CIP-005-AB-7, CIP-010-AB-4 and CIP-013-AB-2 will require all Responsible Entities with high-, medium-, and low-impact Bulk Electric System (BES) cyber systems to implement supply chain security.
A forwarding notice for approval of proposed new CIP-013 and Supporting Standards was submitted on July 25, 2023 to the AUC.
Forwarding Notice Forwarded and Approved
A forwarding notice for approval of proposed new CIP-013 and Supporting Standards was submitted on July 25, 2023 to the Alberta Utilities Commission. The AUC issued Decision 28354-D01-2023 on Aug. 25, 2022 approving proposed new CIP-013-AB-2 and Supporting Standards (CIP-003-AB-8, CIP-005-AB-7, CIP-010-AB-4), proposed new CIP-PLAN-AB-2 and retirement of existing CIP-003-AB-5, CIP-005-AB-5, CIP-010-AB-1, CIP-PLAN-AB-1 effective Oct. 1, 2024 (except for CIP-003-AB-8, requirement R2, which will have a staggered implementation timeline as detailed within the AESO’s application).
For information regarding the decision please visit the Commission’s eFiling site and go to proceeding #28354.
Background
The AESO consulted with Stakeholders on the CIP-013 (Critical Infrastructure Protection) and supporting standards (adoption of CIP-003-AB-8, CIP-005-AB-7, CIP-010-AB-4, CIP-013-AB-2 and the retirement of CIP-003-AB-5, CIP-005-AB-5 and CIP-010-AB-1) which are focused on addressing new cyber security challenges facing the Alberta Interconnected Electric System (AIES). Adoption of CIP-003-AB-8, CIP-005-AB-7, CIP-010-AB-4 and CIP-013-AB-2 will require all Responsible Entities with high-, medium-, and low-impact Bulk Electric System (BES) cyber systems to implement supply chain security.
A forwarding notice for approval of proposed new CIP-013 and Supporting Standards was submitted on July 25, 2023 to the AUC.
-
AESO Reply Letter | July 7, 2023
CLOSED: This discussion has concluded.Purpose
On April 28, 2023, the AESO issued a consultation letter regarding proposed CIP-013 and Supporting Standards and requested Stakeholder comments on the same. For additional information, please see the Consultation Letter
AESO Reply to Stakeholders
On May 31, 2023, the AESO posted written Stakeholder comments received regarding CIP-013 and Supporting Standards, draft amended AESO ID #2015-003RS, Guidance Information for CIP Standards (“ID #2015-003RS”), and the related Reliability Standard Audit Worksheets.
Based on comments received, the AESO has made amendments to proposed CIP-PLAN-AB-2 and draft ID #2015-003RS. In addition, editorial changes have been made to CIP-003-AB-8, CIP-005-AB-7, CIP-010-AB-4, and CIP-013-AB-2. All changes made are reflected in the posted blackline and clean copies.
AESO Reply Letter Materials
Can be found in the AESO Materials section.
-
Written Consultation 2 | April 28-May 23, 2023
CLOSED: This discussion has concluded.Purpose
The AESO is seeking a final round of written comments from Stakeholders on the CIP-013 and Supporting Standards, CIP-PLAN-AB-2 and CIP Standards Pilot . For additional information, please see the Consultation Letter.
Request for Comment
The AESO is providing two Stakeholder Feedback Surveys (linked below) to organize feedback on the CIP-013 and Supporting Standards. The deadline for Stakeholders to provide comments via the Stakeholder Feedback Surveys is May 23, 2023.
- Written Consultation 2 | Material Stakeholder Feedback
- Written Consultation 2 | Pilot Stakeholder Feedback
Written Consultation 2 materials
Can be found in the AESO Materials section.
-
Reliability Standards Workshop 2 | April 25, 2023
CLOSED: This discussion has concluded.The AESO held a hybrid Reliability Standards Workshop session on April 25, 2023 from 10:30 a.m. to 3:30 p.m.
Purpose
The purpose of the session is to engage stakeholders in an active discussion on CIP-013-AB-2 and supporting standards (adoption of CIP-003-AB-8, CIP-005-AB-7, CIP-010-AB-4, CIP-013-AB-2 and the retirement of CIP-003-AB-5, CIP-005-AB-5, and CIP-010-AB-1). Additional details are provided in the Invitation.
Reliability Standards Workshop 2 materials
Can be found in the AESO Materials section.
-
Reliability Standards Workshop 1 | March 16, 2023
CLOSED: This discussion has concluded.The AESO held a hybrid Reliability Standards Workshop session on March 16, 2023 from 9 a.m. to 12:30 p.m.
Purpose
The purpose of the session is to engage stakeholders in discussions on CIP-013-AB-2 and supporting standards and address stakeholder questions and concerns received on or before February 1, 2023. Additional information on objectives is provided in the Invitation.
Request for Feedback
The AESO is seeking post-session feedback on the Reliability Standards Workshop held on March 16, 2023 from 9 a.m. to 12:30 p.m. The AESO values stakeholder feedback and invites all interested stakeholders to provide their comments via the Stakeholder Feedback survey on or before March 30, 2023.
Reliability Standards Workshop 1 materials
Can be found in the AESO Materials section.
-
Written Consultation 1 | Dec. 9, 2022-Feb. 1, 2023
CLOSED: This discussion has concluded.Purpose
The AESO is seeking an initial round of comments from stakeholders on the drafts of the CIP-013 and supporting standards to understand to key questions and concerns relating to reliability standard content, implementation or compliance. For additional information, please see the Consultation Letter.
Stakeholder Comments
Written comments received from Stakeholders in response to the AESO's December 9, 2022 Consultation Letter regarding CIP-013 and Supporting Standards have been posted. Thank you to all Stakeholders who participated in this consultation. All written comments received will be considered in the finalization of CIP-013 and Supporting Standards.
Written Consultation materials
Can be found in the AESO Materials section.
Signup Banner
Level of Engagement
Consult: Gather input and feedback from stakeholders
Refer to the AESO’s Engagement Framework for our approach to engagement
Key Dates
Lifecycle
-
Written Consultation 1| Dec. 9, 2022 - Feb. 1, 2023
CIP-013-AB-2, CIP-003-AB-8, CIP-005-AB-7 & CIP-010-AB-4 has finished this stageGather written feedback from stakeholders on CIP-013 and supporting standards.
-
Review and Analysis | Feb.-March 2023
CIP-013-AB-2, CIP-003-AB-8, CIP-005-AB-7 & CIP-010-AB-4 has finished this stageReview and consider submissions in preparation for RSW to address stakeholder written comments.
-
Reliability Standards Workshop 1 | March 16, 2023
CIP-013-AB-2, CIP-003-AB-8, CIP-005-AB-7 & CIP-010-AB-4 has finished this stageFirst workshop to engage stakeholders in discussions and answer questions on CIP-013 and supporting standards.
-
Review and Analysis | March-June 2023
CIP-013-AB-2, CIP-003-AB-8, CIP-005-AB-7 & CIP-010-AB-4 has finished this stageReview and consider RSW stakeholder feedback as the AESO refines the draft standards, RSAWs and supporting material.
-
Reliability Standards Workshop 2 | April 25, 2023
CIP-013-AB-2, CIP-003-AB-8, CIP-005-AB-7 & CIP-010-AB-4 has finished this stageSecond workshop to engage stakeholders in discussions and answer questions on CIP-013 and supporting standards.
-
Written Consultation 2 | April 28-May 23, 2023
CIP-013-AB-2, CIP-003-AB-8, CIP-005-AB-7 & CIP-010-AB-4 has finished this stageSeek final stakeholder written comments on CIP-013 and Supporting Standards.
-
Forward to Commission | July 2023
CIP-013-AB-2, CIP-003-AB-8, CIP-005-AB-7 & CIP-010-AB-4 is currently at this stageForward final CIP-013 and supporting standards to the Commission.
Stakeholder Submissions
- Written Consultation 2 | Stakeholder Comments, Pilot Survey [Posted: May 31, 2023] (65.1 KB) (pdf)
- Written Consultation 2 | Stakeholder Comments, Material Survey [Posted: May 31, 2023] (104 KB) (pdf)
- Reliability Standards Workshop 1 | Stakeholder Comments on Stakeholder Feedback Survey [Posted: April 5, 2023] (82.2 KB) (pdf)
- Written Consultation | Dec. 9, 2022-Feb. 1, 2023 - Stakeholder Comments on Consultation Letter [Posted: Feb. 7, 2023] (645 KB) (pdf)
AESO Materials
-
AESO Reply Letter | July 7, 2023
- AESO Reply Letter [Posted: July 7, 2023] (645 KB) (pdf)
- Stakeholder Comments CIP Written Consultation 2 Material Survey [Posted: July 7, 2023] (104 KB) (pdf)
- Blackline CIP-003-AB-8 - NERC to Final [Posted: July 7, 2023] (1.76 MB) (pdf)
- Blackline CIP-005-AB-7 - NERC to Final [Posted: July 7, 2023] (727 KB) (pdf)
- Blackline CIP-010-AB-4 - NERC to Final [Posted: July 7, 2023] (846 KB) (pdf)
- Blackline CIP-013-AB-2 - NERC to Final [Posted: July 7, 2023] (668 KB) (pdf)
- Blackline CIP-003-AB-8 - April 28 to Final [Posted: July 7, 2023] (1.07 MB) (pdf)
- Blackline CIP-005-AB-7 - April 28 to Final [Posted: July 7, 2023] (590 KB) (pdf)
- Blackline CIP-010-AB-4 - April 28 to Final [Posted: July 7, 2023] (704 KB) (pdf)
- Blackline CIP-013-AB-2 - April 28 to Final [Posted: July 7, 2023] (555 KB) (pdf)
- Blackline CIP-PLAN-AB-2 April 28 to Final [Posted: July 7, 2023] (459 KB) (pdf)
- Clean CIP-003-AB-8 NERC-AESO June 2023 [Posted: July 7, 2023] (1.07 MB) (pdf)
- Clean CIP-005-AB-7 NERC-AESO June 2023 [Posted: July 7, 2023] (275 KB) (pdf)
- Clean CIP-013-AB-2 NERC-AESO June 2023 [Posted: July 7, 2023] (191 KB) (pdf)
- Clean CIP-010-AB-4 NERC-AESO June 2023 [Posted: July 7, 2023] (304 KB) (pdf)
- Clean CIP-PLAN-AB-2 June 2023 [Posted: July 7, 2023] (177 KB) (pdf)
- Blackline ID 2015-003RS Guidance Information for CIP Standards - April to Final [Posted: July 7, 2023] (326 KB) (pdf)
- ID 2015-003RS Guidance Information for CIP Standards [Posted: July 7, 2023] (302 KB) (pdf)
-
Written Consultation 2 | April 28-May 23, 2023
- Consultation Letter 2 [Posted: April 28, 2023] (238 KB) (pdf)
- Concordance Document [Posted: April 28, 2023] (342 KB) (pdf)
- CIP-003-AB-8 Blackline NERC to April 28 2023 [Posted: April 28, 2023] (1.92 MB) (pdf)
- CIP-005-AB-7 Blackline NERC to April 28, 2023 [Posted: April 28, 2023] (349 KB) (pdf)
- CIP-010-AB-4 Blackline NERC to April 28 2023 [Posted: April 28, 2023] (445 KB) (pdf)
- CIP-013-AB-2 Blackline NERC to April 28, 2023 [Posted: April 28, 2023] (223 KB) (pdf)
- CIP-003-AB-8 Blackline December 9, 2022 to April 28, 2023 [Posted: April 28, 2023] (1.76 MB) (pdf)
- CIP-005-AB-7 Blackline December 9, 2022 to April 28, 2023 [Posted: April 28, 2023] (294 KB) (pdf)
- CIP-010-AB-4 Blackline December 9 2022 to April 28 2023 [Posted: April 28, 2023] (340 KB) (pdf)
- CIP-013-AB-2 Blackline December 9, 2022 to April 28 2023 [Posted: April 28, 2023] (187 KB) (pdf)
- Clean CIP-003-AB-8 [Posted: April 28, 2023] (1.08 MB) (pdf)
- Clean CIP-005-AB-7 [Posted: April 28, 2023] (290 KB) (pdf)
- Clean CIP-010-AB-4 [Posted: April 28, 2023] (335 KB) (pdf)
- Clean CIP-013-AB-2 [Posted: April 28, 2023] (183 KB) (pdf)
- Existing CIP-003-AB-5 [Posted: April 28, 2023]
- Existing CIP-005-AB-5 [Posted: April 28, 2023]
- Existing CIP-010-AB-1 [Posted: April 28, 2023]
- CIP-PLAN-AB-2 Blackline [Posted: April 28, 2023] (186 KB) (pdf)
- CIP-PLAN-AB-2 Clean [Posted: April 28, 2023] (177 KB) (pdf)
- CIP-003-AB-8 RSAW [Posted: April 28, 2023] (334 KB) (pdf)
- CIP-005-AB-7 RSAW [Posted: April 28, 2023] (403 KB) (pdf)
- CIP-010-AB-4 RSAW [Posted: April 28, 2023] (484 KB) (pdf)
- CIP-013-AB-2 RSAW [Posted: April 28, 2023] (266 KB) (pdf)
- Draft Amended #ID 2015-003RS [Posted: April 28, 2023] (301 KB) (pdf)
-
Reliability Standards Workshop 2 | April 25, 2023
- Invitation [Posted; April 4, 2023] (124 KB) (pdf)
- Draft Amended ID 2015-003RS [Posted; April 4, 2023] (301 KB) (pdf)
- Presentation [Posted: April 18, 2023] (1.23 MB) (pdf)
- Agenda [Posted: April 18, 2023] (145 KB) (pdf)
- Session Recording [Posted: April 28, 2023] (69.4 MB) (mp3)
- Discussion Summary [Posted: May 30, 2023] (323 KB) (pdf)
-
Reliability Standards Workshop 1 | March 16, 2023
- Invitation [Posted Feb. 23, 2023] (122 KB) (pdf)
- CIP-003-AB-8 RSAW [Posted Feb. 23, 2023] (322 KB) (pdf)
- CIP-005-AB-7 RSAW [Posted Feb. 23, 2023] (378 KB) (pdf)
- CIP-010-AB-4 RSAW [Posted Feb. 23, 2023] (435 KB) (pdf)
- CIP-013-AB-2 RSAW [Posted Feb. 23, 2023] (263 KB) (pdf)
- Presentation [Posted: March 9, 2023] (1.28 MB) (pdf)
- Agenda [Posted: March 9, 2023] (140 KB) (pdf)
- Discussion Summary [Posted: April 13, 2023] (321 KB) (pdf)
-
Written Consultation 1 | Dec. 9, 2022-Feb 1, 2023
- Consultation Letter [Posted: Dec. 9, 2022] (242 KB) (pdf)
- Stakeholder Comment Matrix [Posted: Dec. 9, 2022] (329 KB) (docx)
- Concordance Document [Posted: Dec. 9, 2022] (342 KB) (pdf)
- CIP-003-AB-8 Blackline [Posted: Dec. 9, 2022] (1.43 MB) (pdf)
- CIP-003-AB-8 Clean [Posted: Dec. 9, 2022] (967 KB) (pdf)
- CIP-005-AB-7 Blackline [Posted: Dec. 9, 2022] (693 KB) (pdf)
- CIP-005-AB-7 Clean [Posted: Dec. 9, 2022] (295 KB) (pdf)
- CIP-010-AB-4 Blackline [Posted: Dec. 9, 2022] (968 KB) (pdf)
- CIP-010-AB-4 Clean [Posted: Dec. 9, 2022] (375 KB) (pdf)
- CIP-013-AB-2 Blackline [Posted: Dec. 9, 2022] (163 KB) (pdf)
- CIP-013-AB-2 Clean [Posted: Dec. 9, 2022] (126 KB) (pdf)
- Reference Material [Posted: Dec. 9, 2022] (223 KB) (pdf)
Contact Us
If you have any other questions, please contact ars_comments@aeso.ca.